THE SAFE-T-COVER BLOG

What we Learned About Underground Backflow Preventers During the Panel

another flooded utility vaultAs you likely know, one of Safe-T-Cover's highest concerns is safety. It's right there in the name, folks. Safety along with education are two of our top priorities. That's why we recently held a panel discussion webinar on below grade utility vaults. The panel was led by Safe-T-Cover's Cary Wiley, someone that's been in the backflow industry for more than two decades and has experience with the devices themselves and with all kinds of installation practices. He's met with countless water managers, engineers, and others in the wide world of waterworks. Joining him as panelists were representatives from different specialties in backflow. Joe Gildersleeve has served as Water Resource Manager for Arlington, TX for 12 years. Chris Mayhew owns Backflow Services Inc., and has been a tester and instructor for more than 10 years. Sean Cleary is VP of Operations at IAPMO and has been in the industry for 34 years. The knowledge and experience these three gentlemen possess made for an exciting discussion. In case you missed it, here are some key takeaways.

Vaults are Mostly for Fire Protection

In a few municipalities, such as Arlington, irrigation can be classified as low hazard and can be protected with a double check valve. However, for most of the US, irrigation is considered high hazard and therefore requires a reduced pressure zone device (RP) which can't be installed below grade. In addition to irrigation, municipalities across the US are increasingly installing RPs on all domestic service lines as well. The primary exception is fire protection lines. Mayhew says that about 90% of the vaults he runs into are for fire protection. What's interesting is that fire protection lines are considered high hazard if they are using chemicals such as glycol or other forms of anti-freeze. If the design engineers do not specify RP or RPDA in the planning stages, then the standard DC or DCDA in a vault will be incorrectly installed and the water supply will not be sufficiently protected. The owner may decide at a later date to include chemical fire protection, and water managers and fire marshals may not even be aware of the increased danger. One attendee commented on this problem and told us that in Connecticut, fire lines are all considered high hazard because of this. We think that's a smart solution and other areas should take note.

vault floodedMany Don't Consider the Long Term Cost

Repeatedly, the upfront cost of a vault vs the upfront cost of an enclosure was brought up. Our own findings have shown that enclosures actually cost less, but this of course varies across the country. The panelists agreed that contractors typically say cost is the reason to choose below grade solutions over above grade solutions. The increased cost is partly due to having to bring the piping above grade for the backflow preventer then back below to continue into the building. However, the panelists noted that backflow valves degrade faster in vaults because they are subjected to flood water repeatedly over time. Additionally, some testers, including Mayhew, charge more for testing in vaults because of safety concerns and extra time typically required. He also explained the costs associated with bringing out a team to pump out flooded vaults, and how owners are charged for the time lost to pumping them out. Testing a backflow in an enclosure, he says, takes much less time and the safety concerns are practically nonexistent. Arlington currently has a project retrofitting a few hundred single check valves to double checks. The single-checks are installed in vaults, and the city is going to install the new double checks in the existing vaults. This does make sense, as they won't have to consider the cost of vaults or enclosures, and only need to pay for the new valves and labor. However, they may have benefited by choosing to move above ground in the long run. Only time will tell. Other municipalities are moving in the opposite direction and retrofitting their double check valves in vaults to above grade solutions. One example is the Las Vegas Valley Water District, and you can read about their program here.


Intrigued? Watch a recorded version of this vault panel with captions here.


Vaults More Dangerous Than We Thought?

backflow-preventer-vault-floodedOSHA is clear on what defines a confined space. All below grade vaults for backflow preventers are considered a confined space causing testers and maintenance personnel to take extra precautions when working in them. The common concerns surrounding utility vaults are that they'll be full of water and contain dangerous animals or insects. It's common sense that the ladders which have been covered in flood water can be hazardous as well. OSHA is also clear on what defines a permit-required confined space.

"By definition, a permit-required confined space has one or more of these characteristics:
  • Contains or has the potential to contain a hazardous atmosphere;
  • Contains a material with the potential to engulf someone who enters the space;
  • Has an internal configuration that might cause an entrant to be trapped or asphyxiated by inwardly converging walls or by a floor that slopes downward and tapers to a smaller cross section; and/or
  • Contains any other recognized serious safety or health hazards."

Unfortunately, this language seems to be up for interpretation and has led to many municipalities choosing not to consider their backflow vaults permit-required confined spaces. Since there are no permits or signage, some testers don't take all the precautions they should when entering vaults. For instance, many don't use equipment to test for hazardous atmospheric conditions or enter with both an attendant and entry supervisor present. Most testers do only climb up or down ladders with at least one other person present. As someone extremely familiar with the Uniform Plumbing Code and with the relevant OSHA definitions, Sean Cleary urged testers to treat all vaults as permit required confined spaces. He stressed the danger of entering without various types of equipment and without a team ready to assist.

When Will Regulations Change?

None of our panelists had a solid answer for how to remove backflow vaults as an installation option. They each said that it will take a change in the codes, a change in upfront cost, or a universal change to RPZs. Over the past few decades we have seen a large change towards requiring RPZs on more water lines where double checks used to be sufficient, but we're still far from requiring them across-the-board. It's still difficult for many to see that the long-term cost of equipment may be more important than the upfront cost, so we likely won't see much change on that front any time soon either. A change in regulations will likely have to outlaw underground backflow preventer vaults altogether. Mr. Cleary suggested that may happen but it likely won't happen anytime soon. He worries that change regarding vaults will only come as a "tombstone regulation," meaning the status quo will only change after more people have died.

watch the vault panel webinar recording with captions

Related Posts

From the Field - The Safe-T-Cover Advantage with a Damaged Enclosure

Think Outside the Vault: Fayetteville, North Carolina

From The Field: 2022 WASDA Fall Conference Recap

Fire Pump Housing Options Beyond the Building

Heading into the unknown: Another Big Freeze could be catastrophic

3 Reasons Why a Backflow Cover Must Have Heat

Water 2050: Preserving the Future of Water

From the Field: Tips for Safe-T-Cover Enclosures and Protective PVC Coating

Forward thinking in Arlington, Texas: Leading the way with public health and backflow preventers

From the Field: June 2022

Texas Water Show 2022 Recap

What’s in Your Meter Vault?

Is “Vault Mentality” Putting Your Water Supply in Danger and Costing You Money?

Learning to Think Outside the Backflow Enclosure Vault - The Hard Way

The Safest Place for a Backflow Preventer Installation

Installing Fire Dept Connection & Backflow Prevention Valve for Safety

The Dangers of Backflow – Corpus Christi, TX

29 Weeks and Counting

Three Reasons Why You Should Choose an N-Type Device

What Are The Three Types of OSHA Confined Spaces?

Watch This Video To See What Was Found In A Utility Vault

What Does It Mean To Think Outside The Vault?

How Do You Hide A Backflow Enclosure?

How Does a Backflow Preventer Work?

This Is Why OSHA Confined Spaces Are So Dangerous

Above-Ground-Backflow Assemblies Are a Big Winner in Las Vegas

A Backflow Preventer in a Utility Vault Can Be Deadly

What is a Cross Connection Control and Backflow Preventer?

CONTAINMENT VS ISOLATION: THE COMMERCIAL BACKFLOW PREVENTER INSTALLATION BATTLE

Water Quality Drops When Backflow Preventers Fail

Backflow Prevention Plays Small but Mighty Role in Water Quality

Cross Connection Control Spotlight: How LVVWD Avoids Backflow

Backflow Protection and Fire Protection Pit Safety Against Safety

Backflow Testers Provide Critical Link in Water Quality

Still Spec'ing the Watts 909? 3 Reasons to Switch to a 957 Assembly

Webinar: The End-All Discussion on Underground Utility Vaults

Something to Consider with Outdoor Pump Covers on the Roof

Cross Connection Control Managers Work Behind the Scenes to Protect Water Quality

Never Put Your Backflow Preventer Installation In The Basement

What Monitoring Systems are Available for My Valve and Pump Heaters?

See For yourself - Utility Vaults Flood (All the Time)

AMI Water Meters Allow Utilities to Provide Higher Level of Service

Can you have a Fire Department Connection on an Enclosure? Yes! It's a Safe FDC Location

Enclosure VS PreCast Concrete Vault - First Cost Comparison

Let's Get Back to the Basics of Backflow Preventers in Utility Vaults

Are Water Utilities Inheriting Risk Regarding Backflow Installation?

Keep Backflow Prevention Outside To Reduce Risk for M/P Engineers

This is The One Place You Should Never Install A Backflow Preventer

Cross Connection Alert - Poll Reveals Concerning Info on Vault Design

Backflow FAQ - Flooded Vaults, Standard Details, and RPZ Flooding

How to design & Buy a Pump Enclosure

Get the free, editable checklist.

download-cta
DOWNLOAD NOW

CONTACT US

Have a question about a backflow preventer enclosure?
Click the contact us button below and one of our experts will be able to help with your specific enclosure needs.