1. Freeze Damage
Any standing water inside or around the relief valve can freeze, expand and crack the assembly. That is true in Minnesota as well as the southern states, where cold snaps are becoming more common. In 2024, Tallahassee, Florida, and Houston, Texas in 2026 dealt with cracked pipes and failed backflow preventers due to freezing temperatures.
Heat tape, insulated blankets and foam bags trap some heat for a few hours, but none of them is rated to the ASSE 1060 standard and none of them drains the discharge a tripping relief valve produces.
2. Relief Valve Discharge
An RPZ that opens its relief valve is working as designed. The problem is where the water goes next. In a below-grade vault, the water has nowhere to go, which means the test cocks and valve body end up submerged and the assembly itself becomes a cross-connection. In a mechanical room, the discharge ruins flooring, electrical panels and any building system downslope of the valve. Insurance claims and liability exposure follow.
3. Theft and Vandalism
Bronze, brass and copper make backflow devices a target for scrap thieves. A wire cage only advertises that value. All across the U.S., cities like Scottsdale and Denver have reported the same theft pattern for years. As Officer Mark Ortega of the Surprise Arizona Police Department put it, “It makes no sense to put a $500 valve in an expensive cage protected by a $1.50 lock.”
4. Confined-Space and Building-Access Hazards
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics recorded more than 1,000 worker deaths from confined-space injuries between 2011 and 2018. OSHA classifies underground utility vaults as confined spaces, which means entry requires permitting, atmospheric testing and a standby attendant every time a tester inspects the assembly. Indoor installations add building-access coordination that stalls annual testing and drags out approvals.