Three Reasons Why You Should Choose an N-Type Device

Conventional OrientationUntil a few years ago, most of the flange-sized assemblies were derived from a single form factor as in the image to the right. A vertical riser through the floor turned with a ninety and then there is a series of gates and valves, all oriented horizontally in succession, then another ninety back down through the slab.

In recent years, the waterworks manufacturers have perfected a new assembly design known as the n-type assembly. For some backflow manufacturers, this assembly is significantly smaller than the traditional models that fill our landscape today. In fact, making this change can reduce the size of backflow enclosures by as much as 70%! Two other important considerations is the perceived difference in price between the two designs and understanding the head loss difference.

1) A Compact Design

The “n-type” backflow preventer solutions turn the shutoff valves into the vertical plane and place the nineties within the boundaries of the shutoff valves rather than beyond them. The result is a much more compact assembly. And with a smaller assembly, you get a much smaller backflow cover - for some backflow brands the enclosure can be as much as 70% smaller. Let's take a look at an example.

Outdated Backflow Prevention Device New N-Type Backflow Preventer in Small Industrial Enclosure

On the left we have the familiar horizontal or inline backflow preventer assembly (BPA), the design that has been around for decades. This is an 8-inch backflow system and it sports a hefty wye strainer immediately prior to the backflow assembly. When fitted with OS&Y valve shut-offs (not shown), the backflow cover for this bad boy is twelve feet long and six feet, eight inches tall. When a property owner is forced to drive around this as he enters his property, it is said that he is often overcome with the sudden urge to knock somebody out.

Alternatively, on the right we see another 8-inch backflow system. The BPA is an n-pattern design. The backflow cover for this baby is just five feet, four inches square, and it’s 62 inches tall, even with OS&Y valve shut-offs!  Which solution would you prefer? If your client has a choice, there is little doubt which version will be preferred. But these n-types have not caught on. The sales rep for a large waterworks distributor in Texas recently guessed that of all the BPAs they ship in and around the state, about 2% are n-type.

2) Demystifying The Cost
Two RPZ Valve Types

These BPAs are not being offered on supply house bids because they’re more expensive. Not much more, but more, nonetheless. At the end of the day, when discounts are added and deals are tightened, the n-pattern assembly is unavoidably about 8% more expensive. When a supply house bids an entire project, they are seeking to win the bid by offering the contractor the best price. Suggesting a more expensive BPA than is absolutely necessary, even if it’s only a few hundred dollars more, is a sure-fire way to lose the total bid package.

The good news for your client is that at the end of the day the total package, including the BPA and the backflow enclosure, is not more expensive. Because these assemblies can be so much more compact, the enclosures that surround them are much smaller and therefore, less expensive: enough to offset the added cost. Of course, supply houses are usually aware of this, but while the BPA is commonly part of the initial bid package, the industrial enclosure is often not. That omission, the lack of a backflow cover in the bid list, hides the evening effect of the total package cost. So even though the property owner is getting a higher preference, which in the hallowed halls of economic theory means it is worth more, the solution is often less expensive.

So even if you are reluctant to specify an actual model number from a specific manufacturer, you should always specify n-type as the assembly type because while some are smaller than others, every n-pattern design from all the major manufacturers is smaller than their conventional brethren.

Learn about even more trends in backflow preventer design and installation in our free guide.


3) Negligible Difference in Head LossRated Flow Chart 957n

If you compare the flow rates and pressure drops of all the major backflow manufacturers (Watts, Wilkins, Ames, Febco and Apollo), you will find there is a negligible difference between n-pattern and inline style backflow preventers. You can see an example to the right for a 4" Watts 957 RPZ (reduced pressure zone) backflow preventer. The three lines represent a z-pattern, n-pattern, and horizontal (inline). In most cases, the pressure drops are virtually identical. The largest exception is only a 2.5lb differential, which is still a tiny margin when considering hundreds of gallons per minute. You may be surprised to learn there are also a few examples of the n-pattern actually having a lower pressure drop than the inline style. This can probably be attributed to the hydraulics of the incoming pressure being "siphoned" by the outlet pressure. Regardless, the overall analysis reveals a minimal pressure drop difference between inline style backflow preventers and n-type style.

Look at the Big Picture

These n-pattern backflow preventers are becoming more prevalent. It makes sense. For some backflow manufacturers they are much smaller than the old school inline devices - up to 70% smaller. However, they are sometimes dismissed because of outdated arguments about price and head loss. As you know now, it is actually more cost effective to specify an n-type in an enclosure, because the enclosure will be significantly less expensive. The old argument about increased head loss is also easily debunked with a look at the flow rates and pressure drops of all the major backflow manufacturers. It's time to stop focusing on the now irrelevant downsides, and see the big picture. An n-type backflow preventer is a better choice than the traditional inline device.

Download Now

Related Posts

One Step Ahead: A Look at High-Hazard Cross-Connections and Compliance

IoT Takes Backflow Prevention To Another Level

Protection from Sound and Fury: Safe-T-Cover Enclosures and Noise Dampening

From the Field - The Safe-T-Cover Advantage with a Damaged Enclosure

Think Outside the Vault: Fayetteville, North Carolina

From The Field: 2022 WASDA Fall Conference Recap

Fire Pump Housing Options Beyond the Building

Heading into the unknown: Another Big Freeze could be catastrophic

3 Reasons Why a Backflow Cover Must Have Heat

Water 2050: Preserving the Future of Water

From the Field: Tips for Safe-T-Cover Enclosures and Protective PVC Coating

Why RPZ Valves Are Required and How to Install One

How To Design A Pump Enclosure


From the Field – National Backflow Prevention Day

Forward thinking in Arlington, Texas: Leading the way with public health and backflow preventers

Enclosure Checklist: Summertime is the right time to think about winter

Enclosures for Control Valves

From the Field: June 2022

Introducing the MUNI-LOK from Safe-T-Cover

Customizing your aluminum enclosure for pipe penetration

Keep Pump Equipment Cool During Summer Heat

Texas Water Show 2022 Recap

Aluminum Enclosure Spring Maintenance Checklist

3 Reasons to Use Above-Ground Backflow Enclosures and Meters — from Water Contamination to Injury

Heated Backflow Enclosure — Comparing Names, Products & Vendors

Installing Fire Dept Connection & Backflow Prevention Valve for Safety

What is a Backflow Enclosure?

Should I Cover My Well Pump? (Well Pump Cover Info)

New Safe-T-Cover LES Models

Backflow Covers: Smaller Footprint Saves Space

The Right Way to Improve Backflow Cover Aesthetics — Use Landscaping

How to Quickly and Safely Remove a Safe-T-Cover Roof

3 Tips for Securing Equipment and Accessories to Interior Enclosure Walls

The Drawbacks to Using a Backflow Cage

Top 6 Questions About Covering a Pressure Reducing Valve Station

Virtual Trade Shows Aren't Perfect, But They are Effective

5 Ways Panel Design Equipment Covers Offer Superior Flexibility

The Best Way to Landscape Around a Backflow Enclosure


Quintessential List of Backflow Preventer Enclosure FAILS

Case Study - Water Corrosion Control System Enclosure

Project Engineer vs. Maintenance - A Valve & Pump Covers Tug-of-War

How are Backflow Covers Made?

Chicago Backflow Incident of 1933

Comparing The Costs Of Backflow Enclosures and Buildings

The Right Backflow Insulation Cover & Heater For You | Backflow Cover

A Backflow Cage May Not Be Enough To Protect Your Backflow Preventer

Find The Right Backflow Cover For You

What Does It Mean To Think Outside The Vault?

How to design & Buy a Pump Enclosure

Get the free, editable checklist.



Have a question about a backflow preventer enclosure?
Click the contact us button below and one of our experts will be able to help with your specific enclosure needs.