Subterranean utility vaults are a legacy installation method with a well-documented record of failure. The USC Foundation for Cross-Connection Control and Hydraulic Research updated its guidance in 2016, urging water utilities to avoid installing assemblies in subterranean vaults. The reasons are structural.
Vaults flood, and flooding creates the cross-connection they’re built to prevent.
When a vault fills with water, submerged test cocks create a direct pathway for contaminated drinking water to enter the potable water supply. Whether those test cocks are open or closed doesn't matter. The submersion itself is the cross-connection — a significant threat to public health. In a poll of engineers and water jurisdictions conducted by Safe-T-Cover, 70 percent confirmed they know vaults flood.
Vaults are also an OSHA-defined confined space. Every annual test requires a certified tester to enter that confined space. According to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 92 fatal injuries occur in confined spaces each year. Beyond the tester, the vault lid offers little barrier to anyone else who decides to open it.
Vault drawbacks include:
- RPZ assemblies cannot be installed below-grade — a code requirement that eliminates vaults for the most common commercial assembly type
- Higher installation and long-term rehab costs compared to above-ground enclosures
- Poor accessibility due to limited internal space
- Toxic gas accumulation, flooding and animal intrusion create ongoing safety hazards
- Numerous municipalities (for example, Las Vegas) have prohibited vault installations outright
Indoor Installation: The RPZ Flood Risk
Installing backflow preventers inside a mechanical room or building is a common workaround, particularly for RPZ assemblies, which cannot go below grade. However, most building owners and their insurers are unaware of the flood exposure this creates.
Supply pressure and assembly size together determine discharge volume, and an RPZ malfunction can discharge more than 375 gallons of water per minute. Typical floor drains aren't sized to handle that volume.