Choosing a Pump Cover: Clam Shell Fiberglass vs Aluminum Pump Covers

huge fiberglass enclosure is damagedWhen choosing a pump cover there are, surprisingly, only a few options for equipment protection. One of the more popular pump cover solutions are clam-shell covers. They are seen as an inexpensive option for protecting equipment from various problems such as caustic environments, the weather, and vandals. They provide workers with an easy way to open the cover and do a quick visual check of the equipment inside. If all that's needed is a view of the equipment, and no repairs or replacements need to be made, a clam-shell fiberglass pump cover will probably do the trick, especially if the equipment is located in a mild climate. However, they are typically made of fiberglass, which we feel is inferior to an aluminum pump cover. We've compared fiberglass enclosures to aluminum enclosures before.

A Quick Rundown of Fiberglass vs Aluminum Pump Covers

Fiberglass is the right enclosure material for a select few environments, as we've stated before. However, it has a few issues which are especially inconvenient for a pump cover. Many pump covers need to be altered or built to custom specifications. This is difficult with fiberglass as it's brittle and repairs and alterations must be completed with a variety of tools and in the perfect weather conditions. If you need to learn how to repair fiberglass or aluminum enclosures, click here. Additionally, fiberglass's color will fade over time and the material becomes brittle or gets holes in it due to UV rays. Fiberglass is also, relative to aluminum, fragile and cracks easily or even shatters. 

Aluminum, on the other hand, is easy to alter or customize. Adding windows, panels, vents and various other accessories is simple because of how easy aluminum is to work with. Customers can even mount the pump cover to a pump skid or make piping penetrations during installation without any worry of cracking or shattering. Marine grade aluminum, as Safe-T-Cover uses, is ideal for many environments and will stand up in the weather for decades. The way we color our enclosures means the color won't fade over time either.

Download the enclosure design guide with the top 5 enclosure design  considerations

Let's Talk Clam-shell Pump Coversfiberglass_enclosures_have_insulation_problems

The most obvious difference between the clam-shell fiberglass pump cover and aluminum enclosures is ease of access. If the pump equipment does need maintenance, an enclosure with removable doors or a removable roof would likely work much better. With a removable roof, the pump can be lifted entirely in and out of the enclosure. There are a couple other key differences between clam-shells and modular pump covers. For one, clam-shell enclosures typically ship pre-assembled. Modular enclosures ship flat and are assembled onsite. Surprisingly, a fiberglass enclosure is often heavier than it's similarly sized aluminum pump cover. This means you'll pay more for shipping not only because the fiberglass is taking up more space, but it also weighs more. Once again, because clam-shells are typically made of fiberglass, you'll have to worry about damage in transit. Sometimes the pump cover arrives cracked. Another big difference between the clam-shell enclosures we've seen and Safe-T-Cover's enclosures is the insulation. We use polyisocyanurate panels which are laminated to a glass fiber reinforced facer on each side. Most clam-shells have spray-in insulation, which has a rough consistency that can trap dirt and other debris. Once again, it's prone to crack during shipping. Modular enclosures, like ours, are made of panels. This means that any panel can become a removable panel or door, and that equipment can even be mounted to the side of a hinged panel for quick access. You can't exactly get away with mounting a control unit to the side of a clam-shell pump cover.

Get what you Really Need

At first, a clam-shell fiberglass pump cover may sound like a cost effective solution to your equipment protection problem. You probably want to just get that decision out of the way, right? Unfortunately, you've got to think long term when it comes to protecting your pump system. That equipment is likely to be in place for years or even decades. In order to properly service it and conduct repairs, you'll probably need better access than a clam-shell can provide. Additionally, you'll want your pump cover to fit the equipment perfectly, which means you may need some custom elements or penetrations. Finally, in order to save money long term, you should look to purchase the most durable option, and one that will maintain its looks for its entire life cycle.

pump enclosure

Related Posts

Low Price, High Cost: Fiberglass Enclosures Are Built to Fail

Lighting and Your Aluminum Enclosure

Beyond Aluminum Enclosures: Our Commitment to Corporate Responsibility

Protection from Sound and Fury: Safe-T-Cover Enclosures and Noise Dampening

Aluminum Pump Enclosures vs. Pump Packages

Standing out by blending in: Safe-T-Cover enclosures made to order

From the Field: June 2022

Air Cooler Enclosure Solves End-User Problem

VE Sales (MI) Case Study: Above-Ground Oil Water Separator

Follow This Custom Enclosure Design Checklist To Protect Your Equipment

Selecting the Right Heater for a Backflow Cover

Hinged Access Panels Keep Things Safe in Windy Conditions

5 Ways Panel Design Equipment Covers Offer Superior Flexibility


Project Engineer vs. Maintenance - A Valve & Pump Covers Tug-of-War

How To Size A Custom Backflow Enclosure

How To Ensure Your Insulated Backflow Enclosure Stays Warm

Safe-T-Cover To Discuss Flood Risks at AWWA Conference

The Best Way To Protect Your Backflow Preventer From Copper Theft

Backflow Preventer Testing Should Be Required for Safety According to Expert

When You Should Use Backflow Theft Prevention Cages

What Made Fiberglass Backflow Enclosures So Popular?

Enclosures: Wear, Tear, and Fiberglass Repair

Can Wooden Storage Sheds Work as Waterworks Equipment Enclosures?

Fiberglass Shelters vs Aluminum Shelters - What's the Life Cycle Cost?

Which Do You Need - A Cage or Enclosure?

Enclosures Help With Loud Equipment and Pump Insulation - Keep Your Sanity

When Is A Backflow Cage No Longer Enough?

How Much Do Custom Aluminum Enclosures Cost?

Case Study: Large Pump Covers and Air Conditioning Pump Enclosures

Top 8 Questions About How To Best Shelter Equipment

Choosing a Cover: Grade Enclosure Manufacturers On These Abilities

Case Study: Pump Enclosure with Variety of Custom Features

Multiple Backflow Preventers in One Aluminum Building

An Engineer's Guide to Custom Industrial Enclosures

Case Study: Custom Equipment Shelter replacements

Case Study: Heated Industrial Enclosures for Fire Water Storage Tank

How to design & Buy a Pump Enclosure

Get the free, editable checklist.



Have a question about a backflow preventer enclosure?
Click the contact us button below and one of our experts will be able to help with your specific enclosure needs.